Chinese idiom · 声匠改编 · 3:59
Playing the Zither to a Cow
A musician plays his finest tune to a cow, who keeps on grazing, until he plays a buzz and a moo. The story behind dui niu tan qin.
Other languages · 2 languages
About this story
Playing the Zither to a Cow tells the story behind the Chinese idiom 对牛弹琴 (duì niú tán qín), literally 'face a cow, play the zither.' It comes from Mouzi's Treatise on Settling Doubts (Mouzi lihuo lun), a defence of Buddhism traditionally attributed to Mou Rong of the Eastern Han and preserved in the Hongming ji, compiled by the monk Sengyou in the early sixth century. Asked why he quotes the Confucian classics instead of Buddhist scriptures, Master Mou tells of the musician Gongming Yi, whose elegant tune left the animal grazing, while the sound of buzzing insects and a lost calf made it prick up its ears. This version keeps Master Mou's debate as the frame and adds a cowherd boy who spots the answer.
What it teaches
Speak in a way your listener can take in. The original says the animal was not deaf, the tune simply did not suit its ears, so before blaming someone for not understanding, ask whether you picked the right tune.
Suits
Ages 6 and up
Tips for telling it
- Play Qing jiao soft and slow, then have fun with the buzzing and mooing.
- Ask: was the cow silly, or did the musician pick the wrong music?
- Have your child explain the same thing to a little sibling and to a grown-up, and notice how the words change.
Questions people ask
- What does 对牛弹琴 mean?
- 对牛弹琴 (duì niú tán qín) literally means 'play the zither to a cow.' Today it describes wasting your words on someone who can't understand, or teases a speaker who ignores their audience. Aimed at a listener it is a little rude, so use it with care.
- Where does Playing the Zither to a Cow come from?
- It comes from Mouzi's Treatise on Settling Doubts (Mouzi lihuo lun), traditionally attributed to Mou Rong of the Eastern Han and preserved in the Hongming ji. The musician is Gongming Yi, and the tune he plays first is called Qing jiao.
- What is the English equivalent of 对牛弹琴?
- The closest English idiom is 'casting pearls before swine', from the Gospel of Matthew. Everyday versions are 'talking to a brick wall' and 'falling on deaf ears'.
- What is the moral of 对牛弹琴?
- The original lesson is 'it is not that the ox does not hear; the tune does not suit its ears.' Good communication means choosing words your listener can understand.
More Chinese idiom stories
All Chinese idiom stories episodes →高山流水
声匠改编
琴师伯牙心里想着高山,钟子期就听出了高山;想着流水,钟子期就听出了流水。钟子期去世后,伯牙摔破了琴,一辈子再也没有弹过。
管鲍之交
声匠改编
管仲做买卖多拿钱、打仗往回跑,人人笑话他,只有鲍叔牙始终信他。后来鲍叔牙把这个“对头”推荐给齐桓公,管仲帮齐国成了霸主。
Learning to Walk in Handan
声匠改编
A young man goes to Handan to learn its stylish walk, copies everyone, forgets how to walk at all, and crawls home. The story behind han dan xue bu.
鹤立鸡群
声匠改编
嵇绍第一次来到洛阳,站在熙熙攘攘的人群里,有人说他像一只野鹤站在鸡群中间。王戎听了却笑道:“你是没见过他的父亲啊!”
画饼充饥
声匠改编
魏明帝要选一位中书郎,叮嘱卢毓别只看名气:名声就像在地上画的饼,看着香,却不能吃。嘴馋的小内侍真去画了一张饼,卢毓则说出了怎样才能挑到真人才。
画龙点睛
声匠改编
南朝画家张僧繇在金陵安乐寺的墙上画了四条白龙,偏不画眼睛,说一点睛龙就会飞走。众人不信,硬要他点,结果雷电破壁……