VoiceSmiths vs ElevenLabs
ElevenLabs sets the quality bar for AI speech and is the reference point for the whole category.
| 項目 | 声匠 VoiceSmiths | ElevenLabs |
|---|---|---|
| Speech model | Built on ElevenLabs models, so the audio is the same lineage | Their own models, newest features first |
| Chinese output | Chinese voices hand-picked and audited, with a polyphone dictionary | Chinese supported, but you sift the library yourself |
| Payment | Alipay and cards | Cards only |
| Lowest spend | $3.90 one-time trial pack / $7.90 a month | From $6 a month, no one-time small pack |
| Cost per English minute | About $0.50–0.79 on the monthly plans | About $0.20 on Starter ($6 a month for 30,000 credits ≈ 30 minutes), less on higher tiers |
| Interface language | Chinese and English | English-first |
| Voice count | 54 curated character voices plus cloning | Thousands of community voices |
| Caption timing | Character-level timestamps, SRT export | Available through the API |
| Full-cast audio drama | Paste a chapter: characters found, voices cast, lines directed; finding the cast is free | Audiobooks detects characters in a manuscript and proposes voices (since July 2026); Studio is manual |
| Same cast in other languages | Script adapted into 9 languages, each character keeps their voice | No documented manuscript translation; dubbing sold separately |
| Whole books | A chapter at a time (up to 8,000 characters per paste) | EPUB/PDF import, chapter export, publishing to audiobook stores |
ElevenLabsを選ぶべきケース
You pay by card, work mostly in English and produce a lot: per minute of audio, ElevenLabs' own plans cost less than ours (Starter is $6 a month for about 30 minutes of English). New features ship there first, and the voice library and API ecosystem are more mature.
ElevenLabsの公式サイトへVoiceSmithsを選ぶべきケース
Your work is mostly Chinese, you need Alipay, you want a Chinese interface and support, or you prefer to try a one-time pack before committing.
2026年9月時点の各社公開の製品ページと料金ページをもとにまとめています。機能や価格は変わることがあるため、購入前に各社のサイトでご確認ください。相手が優れている項目も掲載しています。ツール選びを誤って失うのは、私たちではなくあなたの時間だからです。